"Trump, Xi and Putin"... Why is Europe afraid of meeting closed doors in China?
Analysis by Nick Paton-Walsh, the multi-Emmy award-winning chief international security correspondent for Ofoq News Network. Three powerful leaders over the age of seventy who control 90% of the world's nuclear weapons meet in one room without a specific agenda, and in the shadow of two ongoing wars. Still mo
Riviera Plus
·8 دقائق read

Analysis by Nick Paton-Walsh, the multi-Emmy award-winning chief international security correspondent for Ofoq News Network. Three powerful leaders over the age of seventy who control 90% of the world's nuclear weapons meet in one room without a specific agenda, and in the shadow of two ongoing wars. The topics that Presidents Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping will discuss during their unprecedented tripartite meeting in the Chinese city of Shenzhen on Thursday remain vague and undefined.
Perhaps here is the crux of the matter: High-level summits like this usually set clear outcomes in advance, and are the culmination of months of intense planning and messaging. But everything that preceded the Shenzhen meeting loses its importance in the presence of an unexpected person like Trump.
It was indicated that “preventing nuclear proliferation” would be a main focus of discussion, although it is not expected that significant progress will be made in this file, in addition to the issue of “preserving world peace,” which China has included on the agenda. Suddenly, Trump raised other issues such as Iran, Ukraine, and Nvidia, and even hinted at the possibility of holding a meeting with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un.
It is not unusual for world leaders to deviate from the script prepared for them, but rarely has this matter entailed risks of the magnitude of those expected Thursday, especially regarding Ukraine. On Monday, Trump touched on the longest ongoing war in Europe, through a slip of the tongue mixed with a sarcastic tone.
Trump described Ukraine as his “favorite topic,” adding: “Ukraine is losing... In the conflict between Ukraine and Russia, there are 25,000 soldiers dying every month.” This is a formulation that almost completely left out the heavy losses that Russia is suffering from his speech.
For Trump, Ukraine appears to be a nuisance. It is a country that has been invaded, has rejected his hasty and concessionary peace plan, and is, in his view, in a constant state of loss. The Shenzhen meeting represents a perilous moment not only because Kiev and its European allies will suddenly acquiesce to any announcements it might make, but they have already become accustomed enough to the vagaries of Washington.
The danger lies in Trump's desire to curry favor with powerful authoritarian leaders, in the nature of what might be agreed upon behind closed doors, and in how that might affect Putin's self-confidence and Xi's view of Trump's mental abilities. Putin has freely been given a chance to appear on the world stage, allowing him to present Russia - if only for a day - as the superpower it once was, rather than a country struggling furiously to regain that status.
A palpable state of anxiety prevails among European officials, as a European official - who requested to remain anonymous - told the Ofoq News network, saying: “Trump is affected by the last person he talks to, and this will be a decisive factor in what he says.” A European diplomat also noted: “It is difficult to expect any positive results from this meeting with regard to European security.”
Another senior European official said that the overall impression left by this tripartite meeting was “very bad for us, of course,” but he expressed less concern about the possibility of reaching a broader agreement. The first official described the meeting as "Putin's dream," as it paves the way for his return to the international arena, adding that a very important issue for Trump will be "who will stand in the middle in the memorial photo of these great people."
The picture that will bring together the three leaders after their meeting will be worth a thousand words in expressing the decline of the West. It brings together the man who launched an invasion against Ukraine nearly five years ago, his main financial backer, and the US president who reversed decades of US policy by pressuring Kiev to accept a bad deal by restricting military aid.
One major risk is that Trump might embrace the Russian narrative — or that false portrayal of the facts on the front line — and feel bound by a hastily struck deal with two powerful leaders he admires. Many European officials, whom Ofoq News spoke to, harbor a distant hope that Beijing will play the role of an honest mediator in this war.
This perception is based on the pressure that Xi Jinping appears to have exerted on Putin to limit the use of nuclear weapons, and China’s refusal to provide Russia with comprehensive weapons during the conflict, as well as Beijing’s ambition to transform into a global superpower capable of making real change. However, this optimistic view ignores the extent of China's urgent need for Moscow not to lose this war, in order to avoid humiliation of another major ally. It also ignores the fact that the United States has dealt very harshly this year with both Iran and Venezuela - which are allies of China - which may make Beijing want to see this "revenge" achieved through the defeat of the "collective West" in Ukraine.
Last month witnessed successive strikes on Ukraine and European NATO countries, which came under the cover of an American “peace process” led by Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, and his friend Steve Witkoff, two envoys who lack diplomatic experience and have hardly any significant diplomatic successes on their record. First, Trump concluded a deal to buy Russian diesel, canceling years of sanctions and opening the door for the Kremlin to boost its financial resources for the war.
What followed was a mysterious halt in US intelligence sharing and Starshield services - services vital to Ukraine's defense against Russian missiles targeting it at night - something that the White House appeared to be trying to suggest had not happened, or that it should not have happened. At a meeting in the Kremlin last month, Witkov described the Russian president as a "humanitarian" after Putin released Stephen Hubbard, a retired American teacher and US Army veteran.
After meeting with Putin's envoy in Washington, Kushner recast the peace process as a push toward a new European security architecture, adopting the Kremlin's narrative that the real aggressor is neighboring NATO, not Russia — which invaded one of its neighbors, Georgia, in 2008, and another, Ukraine, twice in 2014 and 2022. Following the imposition of additional restrictions on the Starshield system in Ukraine during a peace summit, Kushner traveled to Moscow hoping to obtain Putin's "blessing" for Europe to join the trilateral peace talks.
Kushner later claimed that Putin had given this blessing, but the Kremlin categorically denied this. According to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, Kushner proposed providing NATO-style security guarantees, in exchange for Ukraine ceding the rest of the Donbas region.
These are only the announced matters, as it does not seem unlikely that the Shenzhen summit will be considered the culmination of Trump’s integration into the Russian orbit. His public actions do not indicate any other course, and he even went so far as to say that Putin could have been “much harsher” towards Ukraine, a statement that can only be interpreted as an implicit reference to Russia’s nuclear arsenal, especially in light of Russia’s continued depletion of its conventional arsenal in the skies over Ukraine on a daily basis.
This scene will not be a frightening repetition of the “Yalta Conference” (Yalta 2.0), in which global powers shared influence across the globe. The First Yalta Conference in 1945 came in the wake of the most violent conflict in history, as it divided the world between three victorious powers, whose empires then witnessed either collapse or prosperity.
Trump and Putin are fighting failed wars of choice, and they represent - in their old age - an embodiment of the decline in the power of their countries. As for Xi Jinping, he has overseen the brutal, rapid, and astonishingly efficient rise to a global technological superpower, but he is still avoiding his potential “war of choice”: an invasion of Taiwan.
After World War II, history had to listen to Truman, Stalin, and Churchill, but in the case of Shenzhen, history may choose not to care. But the harm is not necessarily limited to Trump - when he appears - echoing the Kremlin’s proposals.
It is also not limited to giving Putin a global platform from which to deliver false historical lectures about Russia’s oppression and superiority, or for Xi Jinping - who is perhaps considered the largest authoritarian ruler in history - to appear as a rational and calm party. The gift to Moscow is how little opposition Putin will face, with the world's two most powerful men likely to give him a comfortable space in private meetings, without demanding an immediate ceasefire or lasting peace in Ukraine.
Instead, the pressure will be on making concessions on both the Ukrainian and European sides. The peace process may witness a new shift that is suspiciously favorable to Russia, giving the Kremlin additional months to try to control small enclaves in the Donbas region, or leaving Ukrainian mothers and children facing another harsh winter.
There is not much time left for these aging leaders - Xi Jinping (73 years old), Putin (74 years old), and Trump (80 years old) - to change the face of the world. Perhaps this is merely a passing symptom in history's trend toward authoritarian rule.
But the time factor makes the remaining two years of this US presidential term an exceptionally dangerous period.
Suggested
Read also
SportsSaudi Arabia advances and Egypt declines.. Here are the positions of the Arab teams in the new “FIFA” classification
CultureThe most famous Hollywood films filmed in Africa
Technology